November 2026
1 of 4
Event marketing
Innovation & trends
After its chocolate PR crisis, Reese’s threw a Halloween block party

Chris
Chief Activation Officer
It’s been a bumpy year for Reese’s.
In February, the Reese’s inventor’s grandson published an open letter on LinkedIn that went viral, accusing Hershey of eroding trust in its beloved peanut butter cup brand by replacing their real chocolate recipes with duller, cheaper alternatives. Given how much mileage this story got, we couldn’t wait to see how Reese’s would approach its most important season this year.
Its answer: a search for America’s Trick-or-Treatiest Street.
How exactly did they do that? Great question. Reese’s scored 150 streets in America on candy sales, decorations, walkability and a survey of 15,000 residents. It then created a Halloween Council, including Christina Ricci (The Addams Family) and Kathy Najimy (Hocus Pocus) whose job was to ultimately pick the winner: East Dudley Avenue in Westfield, New Jersey.
Yes, this avenue in New Jersey got a decked out Halloween block party sponsored by Zillow, but every one of those 150 communities got a bright little spotlight from Reese’s that generated plenty of stories and excitement across those local communities too.


So while this campaign certainly doesn’t fix the recipe (Reese’s is allegedly rushing to ditch the now infamous coated candies for 2027) we do think it’s a start and a genuinely good event marketing move. A Mea Peanut Butter Culpa tour.


